After reading the "Indian Killer", I had mixed thoughts or feelings on who the killer may be because there were so many characters in the book who could have been the killer. My first thought was John Smith because of not knowing his true heritage. But then my attention turned to Reggie because of the abuse he suffered at the hands of his father. I guess the true identity of the killer may never be determined, but the novel is a good "whos who" with it's twist and turns.